Collusion to Control a Powerful Customer: Amazon, E-Books, and Antitrust Policy
Posted by Social Science Research Network
Collusion to Control a Powerful Customer: Amazon, E-Books, and Antitrust Policy – John B. Kirkwood (Seattle University School of Law)
ABSTRACT: In July 2013 a federal judge held that Apple had violated antitrust law by conspiring with publishers to raise e-book prices. Many critics contended that the case targeted the wrong parties; the real threat to competition was not the publishers and Apple, but Amazon. According to the critics, Amazon’s predatory pricing and aggressive use of buyer power were likely to create a monopoly, lead to even higher prices in the long run, and deprive publishers and authors of the revenues needed to develop a rich array of new titles.
The evidence, however, indicates the opposite: Amazon was almost certainly engaged in procompetitive loss leading, not predatory pricing, and fears of an eventual Amazon monopoly were largely unfounded. Amazon’s buyer power, moreover, was not monopsony power, which is frequently harmful, but countervailing power, which can lead to lower consumer prices. Finally, there was no evidence that Amazon’s exercise of this power had adversely affected the number or variety of new books.
While the e-books conspiracy was unjustified, the larger issue remains: whether collusion to control a powerful customer can ever be justified. This article concludes, contrary to prevailing law, that it can. It also develops, in more detail than any prior effort, a workable defense for such behavior. The defense is demanding, but when the facts are established, it would provide a remedy for anticompetitive buyer power that antitrust law would otherwise not reach.
Featured News
Geradin Partners Expands Paris Office with Key Hire
Aug 30, 2024 by
CPI
Judge Accuses Google of ‘Clear Abuse’ in Antitrust Case Over Deleted Employee Chats
Aug 29, 2024 by
CPI
Hong Kong Cleaning Company Employee Charged in Historic Antitrust Investigation Case
Aug 29, 2024 by
CPI
Inside the Yelp Suit: Allegations of Google’s Abuse of Search Power
Aug 29, 2024 by
CPI
AI Safety Bill Clears Hurdle in California, Heads to Governor’s Desk
Aug 29, 2024 by
CPI
Antitrust Mix by CPI
Antitrust Chronicle® – State Attorneys General
Aug 22, 2024 by
CPI
CPI Talks… …With Attorney General Phil Weiser
Aug 22, 2024 by
CPI
The Bipartisan Miracle of State Antitrust Enforcement
Aug 22, 2024 by
Gwendolyn J. Lindsay Cooley
Recent Developments in State Antitrust Enforcement: Agriculture and Food Markets
Aug 22, 2024 by
Elizabeth R. Odette
State Attorneys General: Stewards of Consumer Health and Welfare
Aug 22, 2024 by
Brooke Howlett Lovrovich