Tim Wu, a professor at Columbia University’s law school, is Brandeis’s most avid contemporary disciple. In “The Curse of Bigness,” he borrows Brandeis’s impassioned rhetoric to express his fear that a new Gilded Age is upon us, with Google, Facebook, Apple and Amazon appearing as the successors to the dominant trusts of more than 100 years ago. By blindly forgetting the lessons of history, we now face, in Mr. Wu’s words, “extreme economic concentration,” which “yields gross inequality and material suffering, feeding an appetite for nationalistic and extremist leadership.”
Mr. Wu writes with elegance, conviction, knowledge—and certitude. But he goes over the top in his effort to slay the dragon of the so-called Chicago School of antitrust analysis, which finds its clearest expression in the late Robert Bork’s influential 1978 book, “The Antitrust Paradox.” Bork and the Chicago School insist that “consumer welfare” should be the sole standard for antitrust law. Nothing else matters.
There are, of course, some limited points on which Mr. Wu accepts Bork’s conclusions. Both men oppose monopoly power whenever it occurs. Mr. Wu seems to accept Bork’s concern that the over-enforcement of the antitrust law led to perverse Supreme Court decisions, like Brown Shoe (1962) and Von’sGrocery (1966). Both cases struck down mergers between tiny firms whose efficiency gains dwarfed any supposed social losses from increased market concentration.
Featured News
CMA Fines Tereos £25,000 for Failing to Provide Key Information in Merger Probe
Sep 27, 2024 by
CPI
Google Defends Its Role in Online Advertising Market in Antitrust Trial
Sep 27, 2024 by
CPI
Musk’s X Requests Brazil Supreme Court to Resume Service After Shutdown
Sep 26, 2024 by
CPI
Visa Acquires AI Firm Featurespace to Enhance Fraud Prevention
Sep 26, 2024 by
CPI
Visa Gears Up for Legal Fight with DOJ Over Debit Card Monopoly Allegations
Sep 26, 2024 by
CPI
Antitrust Mix by CPI
Antitrust Chronicle® – Refusal to Deal
Sep 27, 2024 by
CPI
Antitrust’s Refusal-to-Deal Doctrine: The Emperor Has No Clothes
Sep 27, 2024 by
Erik Hovenkamp
Why All Antitrust Claims are Refusal to Deal Claims and What that Means for Policy
Sep 27, 2024 by
Ramsi Woodcock
The Aspen Misadventure
Sep 27, 2024 by
Roger Blair & Holly P. Stidham
Refusal to Deal in Antitrust Law: Evolving Jurisprudence and Business Justifications in the Align Technology Case
Sep 27, 2024 by
Timothy Hsieh