The Single Entity Battle Continues: American Needle and the Seventh Circuit’s Hybrid Approach
This article is part of a Chronicle. See more from this Chronicle
Gabe Feldman, May 27, 2009
Courts have long struggled to articulate a coherent or sensible approach to applying the Sherman Act to sports leagues. While Major League Baseball avoided the complications through its infamous judicial exemption from the antitrust laws, antitrust decisions involving other professional sports leagues are riddled with inconsistencies and confusion. The Seventh Circuit recently added to the morass with its decision in American Needle. In American Needle, the plaintiff, a manufacturer and designer of sports apparel, brought an antitrust suit challenging the decision of the National Football League (“NFL”) and its teams (via NFL Properties) to enter into an exclusive licensing relationship with Reebok for the manufacture and sale of headwear bearing NFL team logos. The NFL moved for summary judgment, arguing that it was immune from Section 1 scrutiny because it functions as a single entity… [and]…sports leagues have long viewed the single entity defense as the antitrust “holy grail.”
Links to Full Content
Featured News
Apple Wins Dismissal of iCloud Antitrust Lawsuit, but Plaintiffs May Refile
Mar 3, 2025 by
CPI
US FCC Chief Warns EU’s Content Law Clashes with American Free Speech
Mar 3, 2025 by
CPI
Sutter Health Settles Monopoly Pricing Suit Ahead of Trial
Mar 3, 2025 by
CPI
Spanish Regulators to Decide Fate of BBVA’s 12.28 Billion Euro Sabadell Bid
Mar 3, 2025 by
CPI
Reddit Co-Founder Joins Bid to Acquire TikTok’s US Operations
Mar 3, 2025 by
CPI
Antitrust Mix by CPI
Antitrust Chronicle® – Self-Preferencing
Feb 26, 2025 by
CPI
Platform Self-Preferencing: Focusing the Policy Debate
Feb 26, 2025 by
Michael Katz
Weaponized Opacity: Self-Preferencing in Digital Audience Measurement
Feb 26, 2025 by
Thomas Hoppner & Philipp Westerhoff
Self-Preferencing: An Economic Literature-Based Assessment Advocating a Case-By-Case Approach and Compliance Requirements
Feb 26, 2025 by
Patrice Bougette & Frederic Marty
Self-Preferencing in Adjacent Markets
Feb 26, 2025 by
Muxin Li