President Donald Trump last week sent the Senate a bipartisan slate of four nominees to fill vacant seats at the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). If confirmed, the nominees could reshape the agencies’ approaches to crypto regulations, according to a Friday (Nov. 13) Decrypt report.
The slate pairs a Democrat and a Republican for each agency, marking the first time Trump has nominated a Democrat for either regulator.
The nominations are important due to how depleted the agencies have become, particularly the CFTC, which has been operating with Chairman Michael Selig as the lone Senate-confirmed commissioner. By law, both agencies are meant to have five commissioners, and at least three Senate-confirmed members are required to have a quorum. Filling the two seats at the CFTC would give it the legal authority to turn its proposals into more durable rules.
The SEC currently has a quorum, but two of its members’ terms are expiring and expected to leave the agency. If those seats remain empty, Chairman Paul Atkins would be the only Senate-confirmed commissioner.
All of the nominees have had previously involvement with crypto matters. Both CFTC nominees are drawn from the Senate Agriculture Committee, which has jurisdiction over the agency. Republican nominee Nathan Anonick is currently is legislative counsel to committee Chairman John Boozman, R-Ark., and was a lead negotiator on the committee’s portion of the Clarity Act.
Democratic nominee Matthew Rowland is a career CFTC attorney detailed to the Agriculture Committee who also worked on the Clarity Act and an earlier 2024 crypto bill. According to Decrypt, his enforcement-focused background and party affiliation could add a dissenting voice to the commission, which, under Selig, has aggressively promoted crypto.
At the SEC, the nominees would replace two members who have been heavily involved in crypto policy, albeit in opposite ways. Republican nominee Steven Levine is tapped to replace Hester Peirce, the head of the SEC’s Crypto Task Force and the agency’s most vocal supporter of the industry.
Levine has not publicly revealed his own views on crypto and digital assets, per Decrypt, making him a potential wildcard in the SEC’s crypto policymaking.
Democratic SEC nominee Kristin Johnson would replace frequent crypto skeptic Caroline Crenshaw. A former CFTC commissioner, Johnson was a prominent voice on digital-asset custody and DeFi and pressed for stronger customer protections and conflict-of-interest rules.
The timing of the nominations is notable. Trump has not put forth nominees for any of the seats for a year or more, following his withdrawal of nomination for CFTC Chair Brian Quintenz in the wake of Quintenz’s clash with Trump allies the Winklevoss brothers.
With the collapse of the Clarity Act, however, the crypto policy discussion shifted to the two agencies, both of which moved aggressively to try to institute the legislation’s aims by rule. That made ensuring each has a legal quorum critical to giving those rules durable force.
The window for confirming Trump’s nominees is tight, however. The current Congress has roughly a month to run before the Christmas break, after which control of both chambers will switch to the Democrats. Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., a prominent critic of the crypto industry and the Trump family’s involvement in it, is expected to become chair of the Senate Banking Committee, which would be responsible for confirming nominees to the SEC. If Trump’s nominees are not confirmed during the Republican-controlled session, their road to confirmation could get much rockier.
The Senate Agriculture Committee, which oversees the CFTC, is more of a wildcard. Its current ranking member, Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., who might have been expected to take the gavel in the new Congress, is leaving to become governor of Minnesota. One of its other Democratic members, Dick Durbin of Illinois, is retiring after the current term, and another, John Fetterman of Pennsylvania, has threatened to leave the party over the election of the Senate Majority Leader.
Regardless of who becomes chair, however, the committee will have a Democratic majority come January, which could alter the panel’s generally pro-crypto lean.